Think about why a regular pentagon cannot be created. (1)
Outline: "explanation of the reason why a cube's cut surface can not be a regular pentagon.

Learning activities ... Learning activities     Teacher's instructions/guide ... Teacher's instructions/guide     Evaluation (expected student responses)   ... Evaluation (expected student responses)   

Regarding the necessary software data for using "Cabri 3D File" and "Flash Movie" on the pages, please review [Installing necessary software] .
PDF for print

Learning content

Teacher's instructions/guide Present again the sketch submitted the previous time, and confirm that it seemed to be possible to create a "regular triangle," a "rhombus," and a "regular hexagon" when the cube was cut through a plane.
Learning activities Regarding the case where a cut surface become a "regular triangle," a "rhombus," or a "regular hexagon," observe them from various directions using Cabri 3D.
A regular triangle Flash
Cutting of a cube: sample 1 cabri
A rhombus Flash
Cutting of a cube: sample 2 cabri
A hexagon-shaped cut surface Flash
Cutting of a cube: sample 3 cabri
Learning activities Based on the content learned the previous time, confirm that it seemed to be impossible to create a regular pentagon when the cube was cut through a plane.
Teacher's instructions/guide Ask: "Is it true that a regular pentagon cannot be created no matter what cutting method is used?"
Teacher's instructions/guide Present a sketch that looks like a regular pentagon, and request observation of an actual cubic object created from Sty r ofoam.
Teacher's instructions/guide With operations in mind regarding the question, "Is it true that a regular pentagon cannot be created?" set learning as observation of the cut area when the cube was cut.
A cut surface of a pentagon Flash
Cutt ing of a cube: part 2 cabri
Learning activities Observe while individually operating Cabri 3D.
Learning activities Think about why a regular pentagon cannot be created.
Teacher's instructions/guide Ask if there is a common point that can be said regarding pentagons appearing on the cut surface.
Evaluation (expected student responses) Through various cut s and observation, describe inductively that it seems to be impossible to create a regular pentagon.

Expected responses from the students

A
A regular triangle, regular square, and regular hexagon were produced when the cube was cut through various planes.
B It appears to be an isosceles triangle according to the observation direction. However, when viewed from the anterior, it can be understood that a regular triangle is created.
C It is difficult to know the actual shape of the cut surface when they are not viewed from the anterior. It is important to make observ ations from various directions .
D A regular triangle, regular square and regular hexagon were definitely created. But is it true that a regular pentagon cannot be created?
E When the sketch drawn by the teacher is seen , it appears to be a regular pentagon, but it is probably necessary to observe it from various directions.
F
The cube was actually cut, but it was impossible to create a regular pentagon. Thus, it indeed appears to be impossible to create it. Is it possible to explain the reason why ?
G It appears to be a regular pentagon.
H cabri3D Even when the same cutting method is used, the cut surface look s different according to the observation direction. Thus, it is necessary to observe it by changing observation direction even though it does appear to be a regular pentagon.
I
cabri3DEven though it appears to be a regular pentagon, it can be understood that it is indeed not a regular pentagon when the observation direction is changed.

In addition, all copy rights of the unit structure, Class development, and worksheets belong to Hitoshi Arai (affiliation: Nagano City Yanagimachi junior high school).

[Regarding questions about these pages] nquiries, questions, and any other such matter can be sent with the question form. Please note clearly the question page and content and send via the question form.
CONTACT FORM

Copyright (C) 2006 Department of Mathematics Education, Faculty of Education, Shinshu University All rights reserved.